Getty
An executive order signed by President Trump in early August provides for a pay tax holiday for American workers that could take effect today.
With Congress-led negotiations on the next stimulus package still aimed at providing economic relief during the coronavirus epidemic, Trump announced four executive orders at a Aug. 8 briefing.
The payroll tax holiday is likely to put more money in workers ’wallets, but that’s just a temporary step – one that could bring negative consequences in one way or another.
With the tax holiday starting today, there remains some confusion as to whether employers will participate and how to defer employees who are already experiencing financial stress.
Details of Trump’s Parole Tax Holiday
Trump’s executive order directs the Treasury secretary to defer some payroll tax liability.
Any employee who is paid less than 4,000 before tax per bi-weekly salary period is eligible.
Postponement period Sept. December 1 to 31, 2020.
Specifically, employees and employers pay half of the total 12.4% social security tax for each worker. But under the executive order, employers may choose to avoid withholding .2.5% from employees for social security, but each worker must contribute his or her own share.
There will be no penalty or interest on the deferred amount, according to Trump’s order.
But Aug Gust by IRS. The guidelines, issued on the 28th, specify that the deferred payroll tax should be paid between January 1 and April 30, 2021. Any window that is not paid within that window will be subject to interest and penalties. According to the declaration, employers will be able to recover those fines from employees if necessary.
Workers who see an increase in their paychecks this fall could avoid double social security taxes from their payroll in early 2021 to pay back the deferral. But precisely because of the lack of guidance on how workers will be expected to pay deferred payroll tax, it is expected that many employers will withhold tax as usual during the holidays.
Do you have to pay deferred tax?
The president has the right to defer the payroll tax since he declared a nationwide state of emergency in March. In the event of an emergency, the Secretary of the Treasury may change the taxpayer’s liability.
But it is up to Congress to decide whether to permanently waive the deferred payroll tax.
Ron Wyden (D-OR), a ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee, said in a statement that “this bogus tax cut … would be a big shock to workers who thought it would be too late to cut taxes.” Trump’s executive orders in August. “These workers will be paid a lot more along the way.”
It is likely that Trump’s move to defer payroll taxes will face some pressure as soon as implementation begins.
Last month, U.S. The Chamber of Commerce and Industry and more than 0 business groups signed a letter expressing frustration over the vague guidelines on parole tax suspension and requesting the White House and Congress to forgive the delay. “With a general deferral, employees will be stuck with a larger tax bill in 2021,” the letter said. “Many of our members find it inappropriate for employees to make a decision that will force a big tax bill on them next year.”
Potential long-term impact of payroll tax cuts
Trump has been a vocal supporter of payroll tax cuts.
“If I win on Nov. November, I plan to waive this tax and permanently reduce the payroll tax,” he said when he signed his executive orders on Aug. 8.
But while reducing payroll taxes will increase workers ’payrolls, it only helps people who are currently employed. The national unemployment rate has been 10.2% since hitting a high of 14.7% in April.
Opponents of parole tax deferrals say the American economy is not enough for a time when many people are unemployed. There will be a slight increase in people receiving paychecks, but it is likely that they will be deferred from the amount they receive through one-time cash payments, such as the authorized economic impact payment by the Care Act.
And it’s not clear how Trump plans to fund Social Security without payroll taxes. “The payroll goes to programs that Congress has promised to the American people,” said Carl Tobias, a professor at the University of Richmond School of Law.
If payroll taxes were abolished without a new source of funding for Social Security, the funding could run out by mid-2023, according to a recent letter from Senate Democrats to Chief of Social Security Stephen Goss.
The last time Americans got a payroll tax cut was in 2011, when the Obama administration cut employee pay scales by 2%. The unemployment rate that year, in the wake of the Great Recession, remained in the 9% range.
.
