Sad! 19-Year-Old Defendant Has to Pay 3 Million Yuan Due to Burning Coal in His Rented House | Apple News | Apple Daily

A 37-year-old man from Huang in Hsinchu County committed suicide by burning coal in a newly rented luxury villa the previous year. The house became a haunted house overnight and its value instantly depreciated by more than 3.69 million yuan. The owner, Chen Nan, was angry at the builder, the rental management company, and Huang Nan’s son. The complaint requested a joint compensation of 3 million yuan. The Hsinchu Land Court held that the construction company and the management company are not responsible, but Huang Nan’s son must pay Chen Nan 3 million yuan under the inheritance of his father’s estate. The lawyer said that as long as Huang Nan takes out all the inherited property to pay, the part after paying 3 million can be kept. If the property is less than 3 million necessary, the inheritance will be compensated and the short part will not have to be paid by your father.

Owner Chen Nan noted that in June 2017, he bought a new luxury villa in Hsinchu County for more than RMB 16 million. Later, he agreed with the builder to lease and manage the villa by a leasing management consulting company and divide the villa into suites for rent. Later, the management company rented one of the suites to Huang Nan for 6,500 yuan a month, but it was discovered that Huang committed suicide in the room on December 16, 2018, causing a house price depreciation of 3,697 .000 yuan, so he applied for construction. The merchant, the leasing company, and Huang Nan’s son jointly compensated 3 million yuan.

Huang Nan’s 19-year-old son noted that after his father’s death, he only inherited a deposit of 21,000 yuan and a locomotive, but that he had already spent 600,000 on his father’s funeral expenses and had to deal with loans and credits for the car, and could not pay Chen Nan. Request. Huang Nan’s daughter said that when she said that her father had a photo of a charcoal stove on IG, and that there was a relationship problem, she rushed to inform the owner, knocked on the door, and did not respond. After opening the door, he discovered that his father had turned black.

The judge investigated that during the rental period of the house, Huang Nan not only had a legitimate job and paid rent normally, and other community residents had never reported him for violating community regulations. Therefore, neither the rental management company nor the builder were responsible, but there was suicide in the house. Death will turn the house into a murderous house, and most people will not want to buy or rent it out of disgust.

The judge asked the experts to evaluate the price. In June this year, the house’s normal transaction value was 16.36 million yuan. After it became a “successful house”, the house price reduction rate reached 22.59%, and the transaction value was reduced by 3.67 million yuan. Huang Nan’s suicide is causally related to the fall in the value of real estate. According to the “Civil Law”, Huang Nan deliberately violated good customs to harm Chen Nan’s interests and should be liable for tort damages. After the death, the heir should be liable for compensation within the scope of the inheritance, so the judge sentenced Huang Nan’s son to pay Chen Nan 3 million yuan.

Lawyer Qian Bingcun stated that according to Article 1148, paragraph 1 of the Civil Law, “The heir shall inherit all the rights and obligations of the deceased’s property from the beginning of the inheritance, unless otherwise provided in this However, the rights and obligations belong exclusively to the deceased. This is not the limit for his own person. ”Therefore, if Huang Nan’s son wants to inherit his father’s 21,000 yuan in deposits and a locomotive, he must be responsible for paying the compensation of 3 million yuan.

However, in accordance with article 1148, subsection 2 of the Civil Law, the debts of the heir to the deceased will be “limited by the inheritance and will be responsible for liquidating them”, that is, the son of Huang Nan will take the 21,000 of his father. After paying the deposit and 1 locomotive to the owner, Chen Nan, he will not be responsible for the remaining 2 million yuan. However, assuming Huang Nan’s son inherits his father’s 10 million inheritance, he will pay the owner 3 million yuan. (Reported by Huang Yixin / Hsinchu)

“Apple News” cares about you

Suicide cannot solve the problem, but it leaves the family in immense pain. Please value life.

Give yourself another chance

Suicide Prevention and Relief Hotline: 1925 (24 hours)

Lifeline Talking Line: 1995

Master Zhang’s Special Line: 1980

It’s hot today – use the employees as sandbags! Hualien’s boss villain wore gloves for 42 seconds