The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which has met with unions and other education leaders as it prepares to prepare a new set of guidelines for reopening this week, has also complicated conversations with some communicative sniffs. But there is hope – a new round of guidance – between both unions and student families – coming this week, will lower the discussion temperature and provide clear markers going forward.
Mixed messages
“There is growing data to indicate that schools can reopen safely. And that doesn’t suggest safe reopening that teachers need to be vaccinated to reopen safely,” he said. (The very next day, Sasaki said that Valensky was speaking in her “personal capacity”, despite the official administration commenting at the Covid briefing.)
Becky Pringle, president of the National Education Association, told CNN that many teachers reacted to Valensky’s remarks last week with fear and anxiety.
“That was the headline: They don’t need vaccines,” Pringle said. “They were very restless and very upset.”
Pringle said she appreciated what she saw as the administration’s urgency and focused on the issue of reopening schools. But he said the rest of Valensky’s comments – making sure schools have access to other mitigation measures such as masking, social distance and proper ventilation – were unfortunately missed by some teachers who were knocked out by his vaccine comment.
Randy Wingarton, president of Pringle and the American Federation of Teachers, says teachers should be given priority for the vaccine, but has stopped considering the need to fully compensate for learning in person.
“Medical vaccinations were not a prerequisite for opening hospitals. They are not a prerequisite for opening schools,” Wingarten told CNN. “Mitigation strategies are a prerequisite for opening schools.”
“What the Biden administration can do is they can do their best to use bullying temptation to make teachers a priority.”
An official with the Biden administration said he plans to repeat this week that the federal government sees teachers as essential employees who should have an immediate priority in receiving the covid vaccine. It is not clear whether the announcement made this week by the CDC will clearly address the issue of teachers and vaccinations.
“We want to keep schools open. We want to keep them safe. We want to make sure they stay open – and this applies to all schools, not just the board,” the administration official said. .Private, affluent schools. ”
Balance Act
At its core, the discussion of starting schools is about how to balance the risk for students and teachers at risk in the nation, as children fall further behind.
Without clear guidelines for safe compensation, the already formidable public health challenge has become increasingly a political messaging contest: Democrats largely argue that reopening decisions should “follow science” – without a clear agreement on what that means – While Republicans have zero on liberal-leaning teacher unions, they have accused the system of making unreasonable demands.
But the fight also cuts into the party line and into more complex and abundant socioeconomic politics.
Democratic leaders in some states and large cities, under pressure from frustrated parents, have clashed with the union, pushing for stronger security measures. Negotiations have largely focused on covid testing of school admissions, teacher accommodation with high-risk family members at home, infrastructural facilities in school buildings, and in some cases, keeping teachers vaccinated safely. But the lack of resources and funding has contributed to the stalemate, which could soften if Congress passes Biden’s relief and incentive plan, which includes new money for schools.
While the Biden administration will face skepticism, especially among historically disadvantaged communities, the new federal guidelines will make a tangible difference for teachers, parents and students.
Stacey Davis Gates, vice-president of the Chicago Teachers’ Union, said, “The CDC’s guidelines do not instill trust and confidence in school communities that have been deprived of pay generations and are being robbed of resources because black and brown children are present.” Said Vice President Stacey Davis Gates.
“How many times have we heard that there is no money for black schools? How many times have we heard that there is no money for schools serving majority-Latin communities? Why do I think this epidemic will be different?”
The 100-day goal completes the reality
Asked Tuesday for the president’s definition of open schools, Pasaki spelled out the administration’s parameters as she teaches individually.
“The goal he has set is for the majority of schools, so more than 100%, to open on the 100th day of his presidency. And that means a little chapter in the classrooms. So at least one day a week,” Pasaki said. “Hopefully it’s more – and it’s clear that it’s as safe as every school and local district.”
In Nevada, the Clark County Education Association, the nation’s largest independent teacher union, is preparing for partial compensation in buildings for younger students, using a hybrid model blended into school and distance learning.
Association president Marie Nieses said she is hopeful the new CDC guidelines will help the fact different from Inupendo, but is angry at her rank from conversations surrounding decisions about returning to personal education.
“Our teachers get very upset when someone says ‘reopen schools’, because the schools are open, they’re teaching, they’re teaching. It’s only through Dell, the model of distance education,” Nice told CNN. That is, clarifies the tone of the discussion. Teachers have gone to stop students in difficult circumstances.
Nice also said the suggestion teachers want to wait as long as possible to get back to their homes that miss the mark. In fact, he added, there is a split in the education association among teachers who have threatened to “leave our union” because they want to return for the full Monday to Friday schedule. However, others are concerned that we are not giving them adequate protection and that we are forcing them back into the classroom.
Until now, the federal government had not been tracking how many schools are open for personal instruction, but the Department of Education recently announced it would begin collecting data this month.
An estimate by private data tracking company Barbio says that currently 35% of K-12 students attend schools that offer only virtual instruction, about 40% study in schools that are open daily for personal instruction, and 25% a hybrid. Going to schools with models.
U.S. Public schools in are largely out of the control of the federal government. But despite the expectation of new CDC guidance in the coming days, doubts remain as to whether a uniform code can be applied to schools in different settings and circumstances.
Waiting for a plan
Still, both policy and political stakeholders appear ready to accept the clear set of signposts and are expecting congressional action to help make the benchmark possible.
Danny Carlson, a policy and advocate for the National Association of Elementary School Principals, said the new guidance could be a “game changer.”
“One of the side effects of the previous guidance was not a consistent version. It was haphazard and tied to politics, which again lost a lot of confidence in decision-makers on the ground.”
The previous guidance came out in pieces and caused confusion when former President Donald Trump called on the CDC to amend it. Now teachers ’unions and other school leaders are involved in the behind-the-scenes process.
But both Biden and union leaders say schools need more funding to meet the new CDC guidelines and safely reopen to draw attention to Congress. Democratic lawmakers are moving to consider a 1.3 trillion dollar Covid relief package proposed by Biden this week.
On Monday, the House Education and Labor Committee released a bill text that would provide K-12 schools billion 130 billion to help students return to the classroom. Schools will be allowed to use the money to update their ventilation systems, reduce class sizes, purchase personal protective equipment, and hire support staff. For example, schools need to use at least 20% of the money to cover the learning deficit by providing services such as summer schools.
“We know we’ll get the CDC’s guidance this week. It will be a little uncertainty.” Said Wingarten. “But the resources of the rescue plan, the availability of vaccines and the teacher’s priority – it’s in the air – and the air is changing.”
Currently, however, teachers’ unions have their own grounds. In Chicago, where the city government and school ministers clashed with the union, Wednesday morning ratified a temporary agreement to return to individual education by order and file.
New York City was one of the first major metropolitan centers to bring students back. Early reopeners, after extensive negotiations last September and October. The subsequent rise in cases – which exceeded the test positivity metric by the city and its largest union – led to the closure in November, with primary schools reopening in late 2020. Mayor Bill de Blasio announced this week that middle school Will start returning by the end of the month.
High schools remained on strict distance education regime.
But even in New York City, which has made expensive new investments before reopening, only a small fraction of students have opted for personal education. And around the country, demographic sketches of people who choose to go to class are underlining the complexities of reopening traditionally low-leaning communities, where school buildings suffer from decades of disinvestment and students are more fit to live in multi-storey homes. .
“We’re in a position to make bad choices,” Wingarten said. “You’re not going to make everyone happy in a situation of bad choices.”
.
