Epic tells the court to push Fortnight back to the iOS App Store


The artist's idea of ​​dinging loss to Epic from Apple's decisions (and perhaps its own).
Enlarge / The artist’s idea of ​​dinging loss to Epic from Apple’s decisions (and perhaps its own).

Epic’s ongoing legal battle with Epic leads to a Sept. 28 hearing, with Epic formally seeking a temporary injunction to force Fornite Back to the iOS App Store.

In a new proposal filed in court late Friday night, Epic called Apple Paul a “monopolist” who “avenges Epic’s ferocity” and “dares to challenge Apple’s misconduct.” Epic cited the developer agreement of the moment as an example that such a change should not be faced in the fight against “illegal contract provisions”.

More specifically, Epic accuses iOS of using its monopoly in app distribution (via the App Store) to force developers to use it. [Apple’s in-app purchasing platform]”

“Apple is a direct competitor to Apple Pal in epic related markets, ready to offer competitive app distribution and competitive payment processing on iOS,” the company writes. “To be clear, Epic will not force Apple Pal to provide free delivery and processing services, nor does Epic want to enjoy Apple Pay without paying for Apple’s services. What Epic wants is the freedom not to use Apple’s App Store or IAP, and Instead, to use and offer competitive services. “

Epic in its iOS version uses the short-term end-of-August brief of “Epic Direct Payments” Fornite Epic writes that as evidence of “customer demand” for the competition of such payment process – .42. iOS Percentage iOS users have opted for a direct payment option over a two-week period. The fact that the direct payment option came with a 20 per cent discount on the over-the-moment payment process could play a role in the result.

“Epic will never see these users again …”

Epic also argues that Apple is already suffering incredible losses from its decision to ban Paul. Fornite From the App Store. While previously downloaded players Fornite While it may still play on iOS, that version can no longer be updated. Thus, iOS players cannot connect with players on other platforms running on the latest version of the game, it is a matter of state in which “millions of users of their friends and family have been disconnected. Fornite Community, which is based entirely on connectivity, ”Epic writes.

“People like it Fornite Because partly on other games Fornite Facilitates the community. When millions of players are forced out of the community overnight, Fornite It just becomes less exciting, not just for the players who are joining now, but for every other player as well. “

Daily Fornite Epic says that Apple’s usage on iOS has dropped by 0%, while its’ s percentage of iOS players who don’t play on other platforms are stuck.

Meanwhile, Fornite The case will not be able to attract new users on iOS going forward, the company says it cannot get back. “The constant loss of Fornite “Instead of gathering for users on all platforms, Epic’s customers will be at a disadvantage,” the company writes. “Epic will never see these users again … Epic’s flagship application cannot be counted as a loss like this.”

If eventually Paul is ultimately dominant in this case, Epic argues that regular financial losses can be used to offset any losses to the iOS manufacturer.

In a ruling late last month, Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers largely rejected similar arguments made by Epic to obtain a restraining order against Apple. Fornite Development on iOS. There was no “irreparable loss” to the epic, Rogers wrote, because “the current chaos appears [Epic’s] Own construction. ”

“Your client has also created this situation,” Rogers told lawyers for Epic at the hearing. “Your client does not come to this action with clean hands … In my view, you cannot inflict irreversible damage when you harm yourself.”

Apple said in a statement earlier this month that “the court recommended that Epic adhere to the App Store’s guidelines as their case progresses, the guidelines they have followed since the last decade until this situation arises,” Apple said in a statement earlier this month. Said. “Submit frequently Fornite Updates made in violation of the App Store guidelines. “

“This is not fair to all the other developers on the App Store and is putting customers in the middle of their fight. We hope we can work together again in the future, but unfortunately that is not possible today.”