The Case of Raising the Price of Equipment from $ 2 Billion to $ 12 Billion: “Backing Up” When You Know the Real Price ?!



[ad_1]

Intellectual people

The fact that hospitals in Ha Tinh bought 4 sets of washers and dryers with a real value of 2.09 billion VND but the contractor increased to 12 billion, all investors said they had done the right process and had open tender. .

According to PV research Intellectual people Regarding the bidding process for equipment packages, it is known that in November 2018, after the reports of the directors of 4 district hospitals (Huong Son, Duc Tho, Can Loc, Thach Ha) and the appraisal reports and La proposed by the Department of Finance, the People’s Committee of Ha Tinh Province issued a decision to support financing for the purchase of washing machine and dryer equipment at the rate of 3.05 billion VND / hospital.

After being approved by the Provincial People’s Committee for the procurement plans and contractor selection plans, the investors that are the aforementioned hospitals will organize the invitation to tender in the form of an open tender.

The case of raising the price of equipment from 2 billion to 12 billion:

Ha Tinh Medical Equipment and Equipment Investment Joint Stock Company is the winning bidder, increasing the trot value from VND 2 billion to VND 12 billion.

However, only Ha Tinh Medical Equipment Investment Joint-Stock Company (based at 85 Hai Thuong Lan Ong Street, Bac Ha District, Ha Tinh City) won the tender with the price of 3 billion VND. / a set of washer and dryer.

The product list includes 1 washing machine, model HSCW-ES35 and 1 fabric dryer brand model HSCD-ES45, manufacturer HS Cleantech, of the same origin from Korea.

Mr. Nguyen Dinh Son, Director of Duc Tho District General Hospital, said the unit is using the above washer and dryer, the purchase price is 3 billion dong. However, the documents related to Mr. Son’s equipment purchase said he was not sure why the purchase was made before Mr. Son returned to the hospital.

“Currently, all police files have been confiscated and the equipment is still working well to meet the essential needs of the hospital,” Son said.

And Mr. Tran Van Nhan, former director of Duc Tho District Hospital, said that the aforementioned equipment purchase process was fully implemented by the unit, publicly bidding on the Internet. As for the price, companies quote and then bid, without knowing how much the market is going to sell.

Thought of buying cheap, “back off” when you know the real price!

After funding 4 hospitals including Huong Son, Duc Tho, Can Loc and Thach Ha with the amount of 12 billion to buy 4 washing machines and dryers, about 9 months later (August 2019), the Ha Tinh Provincial People’s Committee continue supporting 2.7 billion VND for Nghi Xuan General Hospital to purchase the equipment mentioned above.

Talk to PV Intellectual peopleMr. Le Viet Hung, Director of Nghi Xuan District Medical Center, said that according to the original plan, the Provincial People’s Committee awarded Nghi Xuan General Hospital (a unit of Nghi Xuan District Medical Center) 2.7 but then only approved the source about 2.5 billion.

By bidding, Ha Tinh Medical Equipment Investment Joint Stock Company won by 2.65 billion VND, but due to insufficient money, Nghi Xuan General Hospital negotiated and it was reduced to 2.597 billion VND. Currently 2,500 million have been paid, 97 million still have no source to pay.

According to Mr. Hung, all processes, from construction and reporting to Nghi Xuan General Hospital, are fully implemented. Until the tender, it was also widely advertised online, but somehow only the contractor, Ha Tinh Medical Equipment Investment Joint Stock Company won.

The case of raising the price of equipment from 2 billion to 12 billion:

A set of 2 washers and dryers were purchased at Nghi Xuan General Hospital for 2.597 billion VND.

Regarding the package evaluation, according to Mr. Hung, the hospitals have contracts with Global Valuation and Consulting Co., Ltd. based in Hanoi.

“Although the province only supplied power to 2.5 billion dong and still had to owe the contractor 97 million dong, when we bought the above price, we are very happy to think that the units also bought a set of equipment like that before. up to 3 billion dong, 400 million dong more than us. Buying much cheaper is a blessing. But now, when we find out the real price of the mentioned equipment, we just backtrack, ”Hung said.

Mr. Hung also said that all procedures related to the purchase and sale of the unit’s washing machine and dryer equipment are being seized by the Ha Tinh police for investigation.

Tien Hiep

[ad_2]