Why were 19 defendants in the Dong Tam case changed from “murder” to a misdemeanor?



[ad_1]

On September 9, the Hanoi People’s Prosecutor’s Office (VKSND) presented the point of view of the case and proposed the sentence for 29 defendants in a homicide case, against the executor of the public service that occurred in the commune. Concentric, My Duc District, Hanoi City. In particular, in addition to the masterminds in this particularly serious case, the VKS also changed the charges against 19 defendants.

Dong Tam Case: Why were 19 murder defendants transferred to a misdemeanor?  Photo 1.

Representative of VKS read the indictment at trial

The representative of VKSND exercised the right of trial in the judicial hearing that this was a particularly serious case, the behavior of the accused was especially dangerous for society. Just out of greed for material benefits, the defendants repeatedly violated the local government’s correctness, causing confusion to the people.

When the functional forces were in the task of ensuring order in Hoanh village, Dong Tam commune, the accused used gasoline bombs, iron pipes with knives, grenades … to attack the police force. After that, they retired to the subject’s home. Le Dinh Kinh to continue attacking the police force.

To guarantee the life and health of the people, the police and soldiers deployed forces to arrest the subjects. During the implementation of the police force, the three policemen used gasoline and burned to death, causing pain and mourning to the victim’s relatives.

“The conduct of the accused is organized, with the roles assigned to each person, showing the aggressive bully, contempt, defiance of the law. Cruel murder of many people, the behavior of the accused also affected the proper functioning of state agencies , caused disorder and security in the city of Hanoi, causing confusion in the people “- emphasized the representative of the city of Hanoi VKSND.

Dong Tam Case: Why were 19 murder defendants transferred to a misdemeanor?  Photo 2.

The defendants at the trial on 9-9

In assessing the scope, VKSND believes that the defendants Le Dinh Cong, Bui Viet Hieu, Nguyen Van Tuyen, Nguyen Quoc Tien are the main masterminds with the purpose of killing clearly. In particular, Le Dinh Cong and Le Dinh Chuc committed organized crimes, murdered people with barbaric behavior and bad personalities, for which they should be removed from society.

For the group of 19 defendants who were proposed to change the crime from “Murder” to “Against the executor of the public service”, the VKS assessed that the behavior of these 19 defendants all committed the crime. the rest accused of murder, like the defendants, have a legal basis. However, after evaluating the confessions of the defendants in the investigating agency and the confessions of the defendants in court, most of the defendants were peasants and were drawn to the upheaval. He was promised to divide the land, so he joined the “Consensus Team” and followed the subjects Le Dinh Kinh, according to defendants Le Dinh Cong and Bui Viet Hieu to commit illegal acts. By being dragged and provoked, each defendant has committed criminal acts at a certain stage and degree.

Through public questioning in court, these 19 defendants basically knew that due to limited legal awareness, due to the promise of land division, they were blindly trusting and following the Le Dinh Kinh issue. The defendants have been aware of the illegal acts, give sincere statements and repent.

Dong Tam Case: Why were 19 murder defendants transferred to a misdemeanor?  Photo 3.

The defendant Le Dinh Chuc was proposed to the death penalty

In terms of nature, these defendants are not subject to fierce opposition, level participation, crimes with indirect intentional errors and above all not directly carrying out acts that carry consequences. killing 3 policemen.

For this reason, the representative of VKS has applied the legal and humanitarian policies of the State to transfer the misdemeanor to the accused, creating conditions for the accused to have the opportunity to rebuild their lives.

Building on the above analysis, the VKS asked the Panel to declare the defendants in the “murder” group, including: Le Dinh Cong, Le Dinh Chuc, the death penalty; the defendant Le Dinh Doanh was proposed to life imprisonment; Two defendants, Bui Viet Hieu and Nguyen Quoc Tien, were offered a sentence of 16 to 18 years in prison; Nguyen Van Tuyen was offered 14-16 years in prison.

In addition, a group of 19 defendants by the VKS changed the charge from “Murder” to “Against the executor of the public service” proposed: lower sentence of 18 to 26 months for suspended sentence, 6 higher -7 years in prison . The group of defendants “against the executor of the public service” previously included 4 people: Le Dinh Hien, Bui Viet Tien, Nguyen Thi Dung and Tran Thi Phuong, who were offered a prison sentence of 15 to 18 months for suspended sentences.



[ad_2]