Bees defend their hives against killer hornets with animal poop

The bees in Asia have a hard time. Unlike their cousins ​​in North America, where bee-eating hornets have recently arrived, Asian bees are relentlessly hunted by these giant wasps. The constant attacks have accelerated the evolution of Asian bees and have resulted in the insects developing various defensive tactics in addition to simply using their stings.

First, Asian bees build their nests like fortresses, with tiny entrances and sturdy walls. They also aggressively hiss at predators to warn them that they are being monitored. And, if that doesn’t work, they can flood the attackers in “bee balls,” which generate such heat that the hornets inside cook themselves alive.

Now a study published in PLUS ONE, by Heather Mattila of Wellesley College in Massachusetts, shows that these bees have another trick up their sleeves: they protect their homes with manure.

Vespa mandarinia and Vespa soror they are known as killer wasps for a reason. When explorers of these species find a hive of bees, they land and leave chemical markers near the entrance. The scouts then return with up to 50 of their relatives to launch an attack.

READ MORE:
* Scientists eliminate 98 ‘killer hornets’ in Washington state
* ‘Killer Hornets’ Found in America for the First Time
* Video shows the fascinating defense of the ‘Mexican wave’ of bees against predators

Armed with powerful jaws and tough armor that makes them resistant to bee stings, the hornets lay siege to the hive entrance and attempt to rip it apart in order to break in. They are attacked by the guardian bees as they do so, and are sometimes successfully kicked out. But not always.

Often they go in and once there, each hornet kills thousands of bees. This slaughter paves the way for the hornets to catch the true target of the attack, the baby larvae that develop in the hive. These are taken to feed their own young waiting in the nest. That clears the hive.

Wasp attacks are devastating to beekeeping, so beekeepers are keen to find ways to help their loads keep these predators at bay. When Mattila’s co-author Gard Otis of the University of Guelph in Canada learned from a beekeeper in Vietnam that bees put balls of water buffalo manure in their hives after being visited by hornets, it piqued his curiosity.

That, in turn, led Otis, Mattila, and their colleagues to visit Vietnam, where they monitored 339 bee hives. They found that many of these hives were actually covered in droplets of what looked like compost, and that most of these droplets were clustered around the entrance to the hive.

When they monitored the bees’ movements, they discovered not only that the bees were collecting buffalo manure, but also regularly creating globs from faeces collected in a chicken coop and a pile of manure in a pig enclosure. Further monitoring of the hives showed that the bees quickly attached hundreds of balls of feces to their hives after the wasp attacks.

Off the mark

To see if this was a consequence of the chemical markings, Mattila and her colleagues collected extracts from the glands that hornets use to secrete the substances involved. They then soaked some filter papers in these extracts and placed pieces of this material near the entrances of the hives. As a control, they also soaked some filter papers in ether, and distributed them equally near the entrances of other hives.

The hornet extract elicited a strong response. A day after their arrival, the members of the hive created an average of 15 nearby balloons. Ether caused an average of only two. This suggests that bees are wise in hornet tagging tactics and prepare for a possible attack accordingly.

To make sure the balloons really help the bees defend their hives, the team recorded a few attacks. They found that a tightly stacked hive reduced the amount of time the hornets spent trying to penetrate by 94 percent.

Why droplets of feces repel hornets remains a mystery. Mattila speculates that manure contains compounds that antagonize hornets in some way. Specifically, these would be defensive substances synthesized by plants that buffalo, pigs and chickens eat.

If that idea turns out to be correct, then it seems that Asian bees have invented an effective form of chemical warfare.

© 2020 The Economist Newspaper Limited. All rights reserved. From The Economist published under license. The original article can be found at www.economist.com