Adonis’s text in “Literature 1” ignites a debate on normalization … Subject teacher: Objections from those who fail!



[ad_1]

Faten Hajj wrote in “Al-Akhbar”: Some of the Master 1 students in the Department of Arabic Language and Literature of the Faculty of Arts and Humanities of the Lebanese University provoked the contest “Textual Approaches to Modern Arabic Thought”, a text of the poet Adonis who “opens a door to normalization with the Israeli enemy.” Calling for the peace of art and literature produced by Jewish writers and artists outside and within Israel.

The writer defends his thesis with arguments drawn from Islam itself, “Islam initially fought with the Jews without boycotting Jewish thought or Jewish culture, and the Romans and Persians fought without boycotting Byzantine, Greek or Persian culture.” Furthermore, “creativity cannot be identified or united with the institution, and it is, in one nation, an ally of creativity in other nations, beyond political conflicts, hostilities and wars.”

The controversy over the text came to light after the results were finally released, which showed a high repetition rate (12 out of 31, at 39%), and not on the day of the exam 10 days ago, and the reason, According to student sources, it is that there was no consensus among the students on Boycotting the competition, making boycott advocates the only ones affected. Therefore, the opinion focused on addressing the competition and expressing a critical position through it, as long as the nature of the material tolerated it, and criticism was prioritized over the extraction of literary phenomena.

Sources asked about the reason for choosing this text at this time and the delicate circumstances that Lebanon is going through, as the level of conversation about neutrality and normalization rises to which the Arab regimes rush, noting that the range of options before the subject is great. Hussein, Zaki Mahmoud, Amin Maalouf and others “.

The students who objected signed a petition demanding that a second teacher re-grade the contest, and that this teacher also correct the second round.

But the subject for the subject’s professor, Joseph Lebs, “was not worth all the hype that came only from those who failed”, considering that “the examiners are mature and mature master’s students who are fully aware that the material is close to texts in modern Arabic thought, that is, should deal with issues The time and current problems, literature and thought are not separated from these problems. What was required of the students was to understand the text and present their critical opinion, and they were free to say what they wanted, provided that this was accompanied by persuasion and arguments and evidence in a solid Arabic language.

He indicated ambiguously that “delicate circumstances should not make us stop thinking”, asking if what is required is that “betray, incriminate and insult, while the text is at the center of the prescribed program of the article”.

The head of the Department of Arabic Language and Literature, Ibrahim Fadlallah, explained to Al-Akhbar that he was not informed of any objections from the students until after the results were released, “although the matter could have been addressed since the beginning, that is, when the contest was held. ” However, he considered that the professor of the course “did not succeed in choosing the text in which a clear call for normalization appears and contains many fallacies, especially from the point of view of the anti-Zionist Arab discourse, while we try to ensure that the texts presented in the exams are conciliatory and not problematic, given the country’s situation ”. , Noting that «we take the commitment of the teacher of the subject not to repeat problematic texts. We will study the possibility of correcting the competition again and giving everyone their right ”. She was surprised by the campaign against the Lebanese University on social media, and accused it of normalizing with Israel, “while what happened is nothing more than an individual incident to be addressed.”

Read the full article Press here.

Source: News

[ad_2]