China ordered Ant to reexamine its fintech businesses, which range from wealth management to loans and consumer credit insurance, and return to its roots as a payment service.
While the central bank’s statement on Sunday was short on details, it poses a serious threat to the billionaire’s growth and more lucrative operations. Jack Maempire of online finance. Regulators did not go so far as to directly call for the company to break up, but stressed that it was important that Ant “understand the need to review his business” and told him to come up with a plan and schedule as soon as possible.
Authorities also berated Ant for his poor corporate governance, his disregard for regulatory requirements and his involvement in regulatory arbitration. The central bank said Ant used its dominance to shut out rivals, hurting the interests of its hundreds of millions of consumers.
Ant said in response that he will establish a special team to meet the demands of regulators. It will keep business operations for users, promising not to increase prices for consumers and financial partners, while increasing risk controls.
The Hangzhou-based firm needs to establish a separate financial holding company to comply with the rules and ensure it has enough capital, regulators added.
Here are some of the scenarios from investors and analysts on what the restructuring might look like:
Mild
Optimists say regulators are simply asserting their right to oversee the country’s financial sector, sending a warning to unintentional internet companies for a drastic change.
Beijing could be trying to make an example of Ma’s Ant, the largest among a number of new but ubiquitous fintech platforms. Previous crackdowns of this nature have dealt short-term blows to companies, leaving them virtually unscathed. Social media giant Tencent Holdings Ltd., for example, became a prominent target of a campaign to combat gaming addiction among kids in 2018. While its actions took a hit, they eventually rebounded to all-time highs.
Ant affiliate, Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. similarly regained investor confidence after short-term sell-offs following accusations by authorities about everything from unfairly pressuring traders to turning a blind eye to fakes on its trading platform. electronic.
“I don’t think regulators are thinking of splitting Ant, as no fintech company in China has a monopoly status,” said Zhang Kai, analyst at market research firm Analysys Ltd. “The act is not just about target to Ant but also to send a warning to other Chinese fintech companies. ”
Some see it as an opportunity for Ant. With the industry as a whole facing stricter oversight, Ant has more resources to meet the challenges as an industry leader, Zhang said.
Bad
A more troubling outcome would be if regulators decide to split Ant Group. That would complicate the shareholder structure and hurt the company’s fastest-growing businesses.
Valued at around $ 315 billion before its initial public offering was halted, Ant cornered investments from the world’s largest funds. Among them: Warburg Pincus LLC, Carlyle Group Inc., Silver Lake Management LLC, Temasek Holdings Pte and GIC Pte.
Global investors backed the company when it was valued at around $ 150 billion in its latest round of fundraising in 2018. A breakout would make the return on its investments uncertain, with the timeline for an IPO due in November. now pushed into the distant future.
The government could ask Ant to spin off its most lucrative wealth management, credit loan and insurance operations and transfer them to a financial holding company that will face stricter scrutiny.
“The emerging reality is that China’s regulators are adopting similar regulation towards banks and fintech players,” said Michael Norris, manager of research and strategy at Shanghai-based consultancy AgencyChina.
Ant’s payment business leaves much less to the imagination. While the service handled $ 17 trillion of transactions in one year, online payments have been largely loss-making. The two largest mobile payment operators, Ant and Tencent, have heavily subsidized companies, using them as a gateway to win over users. To make money, they took advantage of payment services for cross-selling products, including wealth management and credit loans.
“Ant’s growth potential will be limited with the focus again on its payment services,” said Chen Shujin, Hong Kong-based head of China financial research at Jefferies Financial Group Inc. “On the mainland, the industry of online payments is saturated and Ant’s market share has practically reached its limit. ”
Nightmare
The worst case scenario would be for Ant to give up its money management, credit and insurance businesses, shutting down its operations in units that serve 500 million people.
Its wealth management business, which includes the Yu’ebao platform that sells mutual funds and money market funds, accounted for 15% of revenue.
Lending technology, which includes Ant’s Huabei and Jiebei units, was the largest revenue driver for the group, contributing 39% of the total in the first six months of this year. Made loans to about 500 million people.
That result would be supported by the idea that China’s leaders have become frustrated with the boastfulness of tech billionaires and want to teach them a lesson by taking down their businesses, even if it spells short-term pain for the economy and companies. markets.
China’s private sector has had a delicate relationship with the Communist Party for decades, and only recently has it been recognized as central to the future of the nation. Many commentators have attributed the recent crackdown on fintech companies to comments Ma made at a conference in October, when he condemned attempts to control the burgeoning field as shortsighted and outdated.
Among them, Alibaba, Ant and Tencent earned a combined market capitalization of nearly $ 2 trillion in November, surpassing state giants such as Bank of China Ltd. as the most valuable companies in the country.
The trio have invested billions of dollars in hundreds of internet and mobile phone startups, earning them king-maker status in the world’s largest internet and smartphone market by users.
“The Communist Party is the end of everything and the absolute in China. Control everything, “he said Alex Capri, a Singapore-based researcher at the Hinrich Foundation. “There is nothing that the Communist Party of China does not control and anything that appears to be spinning out of its orbit will somehow retreat very quickly,” he said, adding that “we can expect to see more of that.”
.
