[ad_1]
Harry Maguire’s nightmarish start to the season continued with his red card to England on Wednesday night.
Two reckless tackles for two yellow cards at Wembley spoke of one player whose confidence seems to be shot and another who desperately needs a break.
Following the ordeal of his conviction in Greece following an altercation at a nightclub and then sub-standard early-season performances for Manchester United, Maguire is feeling the pressure.
The international fortnight offered a change of scenery, but no improvement in luck and life is not going to be easier.
United have a daunting string of matches that includes encounters with Paris Saint-Germain, Chelsea, RB Leipzig and Arsenal in the next three weeks.
So should United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer seize the opportunity from Saturday night’s visit to Newcastle United to give Maguire some rest?
Former United defender Rio Ferdinand certainly thinks so and says: ‘In these situations, which I’ve been in too, sometimes you have to take it out of the oven.
‘Whether maybe it’s time to give him some rest, let him recover and regain that confidence.
‘They took me out in a game, I think it was Middlesbrough, the manager [Sir Alex Ferguson] He spoke to me and said ‘go back to basics, train well and you will come back’.
That’s what happened and it was fine. It’s just that sometimes that little pressure taking off can really help him. ‘
Another prominent expert, Jamie Redknapp, also expressed his sympathy for Maguire and what he’s going through.
‘I’m sorry for him. It would be easy to tear it apart, ” he said.
“ He’s going through a really bad time in his career where he’s going to have to somehow bounce back and a great weekend is coming up. ”
But should Maguire play Newcastle or is this the ideal opportunity for Solskjaer to take some pressure off his captain?
Sportsmail reporters offer their opinions on the Maguire situation.
ROB DRAPER
No not yet. It may be necessary at some point, but Maguire had a good game on Sunday, followed by a terrible one on Wednesday.
Obviously 6-1 weighs heavily on his mind too, but that was a collective tactical failure.
His shape has been uneven for a while, so he wouldn’t overreact to Wednesday night. Ultimately, you have to play yourself in good shape. That starts now.
DANIEL MATTHEWS
Yes.
Manchester United have a very tough match streak after this weekend’s trip to Newcastle.
Solskjaer must give Maguire the best chance to get ready (and shoot) for PSG, Chelsea, Leipzig and Arsenal. His performances, and those of Newcastle, suggest he shouldn’t miss much this weekend.
But the damage done if you can’t stop this depression will soon start to snowball.
Maguire’s confidence seems soaring, his displays stink of mental and physical fatigue.
So give him a break from the cameras and a break during these unforgiving hours. The easy decision would be to play with him and hope that he rediscovers some form at work.
But Ole should be brave, ignore the noise, and answer a simple question: is this Maguire costume good enough for his team?
KIERAN GILL
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer shouldn’t leave Harry Maguire. Any England fan should want him as a starter at their club.
The best way for the Manchester United defender to regain his form is to get back on that horse. Clearly Gareth Southgate likes it and will wear it to Euro 2020. So let’s get his confidence back.
BARLOW MATE
That depends a lot on your mood. From afar, it is true, he seems mentally drained and ready to rest.
But Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and his coaching staff will have a better idea about it.
He is Manchester United’s best central midfielder and they have to get him to the top of his game as quickly as possible.
Most footballers prefer to play through tough times and get back in shape, and Maguire is not the type of personality to hide from pressure.
Wanting to play and leave him out against Newcastle would consume his confidence and increase any doubts in his mind about his ability to overcome this problem.
United must show support and make the right judgment, but it will be better if they can keep him on the field.
IAN LADYMAN
It depends on the aptitude of other players. But if possible, yes. A club like Manchester United should be deep enough to get by without one of its players for a game or two, even if it’s the captain.
I was at Wembley on Wednesday and Maguire’s half hour performance before he was sent off was as bad as anything I have seen from an individual player for quite some time.
He seems like a player who has lost confidence to the point where he can no longer do simple things.
A game in Newcastle is a game United should be able to win without Maguire, but they have tougher trials ahead and it’s important that Maguire is the right fit for them.
In fact, I would send Maguire out for a few days and encourage him to recharge. It wouldn’t even take him northeast. If Victor Lindelof and Eric Bailly are fit, they should play this weekend.
JOE BERNSTEIN
No, Harry Maguire should play. He’s been error-prone this season but, like Harry Kane, he improves with miles on the clock. Leaving it out now would be counterproductive.
United was a defensive disaster against Spurs, but the reaction to their red card to England has been overblown. He gained enough of the ball to indicate that the second yellow was unfortunate.
If the incident had happened during the World Cup when Maguire was popular, people would be yelling injustice.
There are suggestions that he is mentally gone due to the problems he faces in Greece. United may say so in training, but I would be surprised.
This is a player who has made the hard yards at Sheffield United and Hull to become Manchester United captain.
ADRIAN KAJUMBA
Under normal circumstances, the answer would be yes. Harry Maguire’s shaky displays for the club and now the country would justify pulling him out of the line of fire.
However, it is a damning indictment of Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s alternative options that Manchester United still look weaker without Maguire, even with the way he is.
Victor Lindelof is simply not good enough, while Eric Bailly has struggled for consistency in his fitness and form.
Axel Tuanzebe is talented, but has suffered an injury and has just returned from his latest setback. Great things are expected from Teden Mengi, but he’s just getting started and it might be too much to expect him to come in and beef up United’s defense right away.
Phil Jones and Marcos Rojo, meanwhile, are off the scene at Old Trafford.
If I had reliable high-level alternatives, this situation would be an easier decision for Solskjaer. Without them, you can be hopeful that Maguire can get back in shape.
TOM COLLOMOSSE
Yes. The surprise to me is that this question is being asked only now.
Maguire deserves retirement for one simple reason: He was sad in the last game for his club, Manchester United, and his poor performance contributed to a 6-1 loss at Old Trafford to Tottenham.
This alone would justify Solskjaer leaving him, and many others, out of the starting eleven at Newcastle on Saturday.
Any defender of a team that had conceded six goals at home in their previous match could not hope to automatically keep their place in the team for the next match.
Since Maguire was sent off by England against Denmark on Wednesday, there has been a lot of talk about the need to give him a mental as well as a physical break, but only those closest to the 27-year-old can know his state of health. mind.
So the argument is simple: it is part of a defense that has left 11 goals in three league games. Of course, your place should be in jeopardy.
JACK GAUGHAN
I’m not sure if United can afford to quit, although the coup against Denmark may offer a good opportunity for a natural break.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer isn’t blessed with a host of solid defensive options and even a Maguire fight with his own performances could be a more viable option than some of the others.
Maguire is the type of leader who will want to correct his form in the next available game and sometimes that’s the best way to get out of a losing streak.
Source: m.allfootballapp.com
[ad_2]
