Epic’s decision to bypass Apple’s App Store policies was dishonest, says US judge

A U.S. judge hearing arguments in Epic’s anti-trust lawsuit against U.S. Paul has criticized the game developer’s decision, pushing the game developer’s version of the breach of contract with the iPhone maker. Fornite With a custom payment system on the App Store. This decision took away Apple’s moment Fornite From the App Store.

During a hearing Monday with both companies, United States District Court for the Northern District of California Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers questioned Epic’s arguments, noting that he did not pose a threat to Apple’s safety because it was a good thing. Established company and partner.

“You did something, you lied about it, you lied, you didn’t come. That is a security issue. That’s the only safety issue! Rogers told Epic, according to a report CNN. “There are a lot of people out there who consider you guys heroes for the work you do for people, but it’s still not honest.”

The three-hour hearing at Zoom failed to resolve any of the open questions in the ongoing anti-trust lawsuit against Epic, including Fornite Returning to the App Store will be allowed temporarily. A decision on the issue is expected “in the coming days.” The New York Times.

Judge Gonzalez Rogers recommended, however, that the case be taken to a jury hearing in July next year to resolve the issue permanently. “It’s enough to understand what real people think,” Rogers said. “Does this security issue concern people or not?”

According to CNN, Judge Rogers said it was “not particularly persuasive” by Epic’s argument that Apple had bundled the payment system into its App Store and app simultaneously in violation of the Play Ant App Trust Act. The judge also said he did not necessarily agree with Epic that Apple Play had damaged its ability to distribute. Fornite Through its control of the App Store.

The judge said, “The gardens with walls have existed for many decades. “Nintendo has a walled garden. There is a Sony walled garden. There is a micro .ft walled garden. What Apple Pal does is not much different … It’s hard to ignore the economics of the industry, what you’re telling me to do. “

The lawsuit between Apple Pal and Epic has become a crying cry for many developers dissatisfied with the iPhone maker’s App Store policies. Last week, companies including Epic, Spotify, Tile, and Match Group formed an alliance for App Fairness, which aims to “protect the fundamental right of creators to create apps and do business directly with their customers,” according to Epic CEO Tim Sweeney.